La Petite Cafe Monticello — The Sandwich King Ep. 2 | Redlow Group

Community BusinessEpisode 2 — Monticello, IN

La Petite Cafe Monticello — The Sandwich King Ep. 2

Redlow Group confronts Cody Miller about his sandwich stack and drags him to La Petite Cafe Monticello — where fresh-cut romaine, bacon, and a 100-year-old family recipe get put to the test.

Michael Sims Redlow Group
Ryan Clemons Redlow Group

Michael Sims & Ryan Clemons
Co-Chairmen & Founders  ·  Redlow Group
Published • Updated
Quick Answer

What is La Petite Cafe in Monticello Indiana?

La Petite Cafe Monticello is a fresh sandwich and salad cafe at 138 South Main Street. Specifically, all lettuce is hand-cut fresh daily from romaine, arugula, and spinach. All bowls and utensils are eco-friendly and biodegradable. Additionally, the cafe operates inside Utter Sensation — serving all-natural 14% butterfat ice cream from the Chocolate Shoppe.

📞 Buy or Sell in Monticello — Contact Redlow Group

For weeks, Cody Miller had been walking into the office every morning with a towering stack of sandwiches on a paper plate — completely exposed. Specifically, after building a collection of video clips, Michael and Ryan finally took Cody to La Petite Cafe Monticello. For buyers wanting to understand what daily life in downtown Monticello looks like, our top choice for homebuyers guide and Monticello community guide cover the full picture.

The Legend of Cody’s Sandwich Stack

01
Cody Miller — Agent, Negotiator, Sandwich Enthusiast

First and foremost, Cody Miller had been walking through the office door every day with a remarkable stack of sandwiches on a paper plate — completely unbagged, fully exposed. Specifically, Michael began collecting video clips of the daily sandwich entrance — hoping either a sandwich would fall. Furthermore, concern eventually overtook amusement, prompting the question: has Cody ever actually had a real sandwich?

Additionally, Cody explained his logic on camera: fewer minutes out of the office means more time focused on clients. Moreover, the sandwiches contain a secret 100-year-old family recipe which he declined to share with the camera. As a result, the team took Cody to La Petite Cafe Monticello. Everyone agreed it was the right call.

“Less time out of the office equals more time focused on my clients.” — Cody Miller, on his sandwich strategy

“Your sandwich sounds 100 years old, Cody.” — Michael Sims, in response

— The Great Sandwich Debate, Episode 2

La Petite Cafe Monticello — 138 South Main Street

02
Fresh Food, Eco-Friendly, and Born from a Real Need

Additionally, the owner of La Petite Cafe shared the origin story of the restaurant with refreshing honesty: she never planned to own a restaurant. Specifically, she identified a genuine gap for fresh downtown lunch options and decided to fill it. Furthermore, chef Amber handles the cooking while the owner handles operations — a partnership the community immediately embraced.

Moreover, the commitment to quality is genuine: all lettuce is hand-cut fresh daily — no bagged lettuce. Additionally, all ingredients aim to be natural and fresh, and all bowls, utensils, and packaging are eco-friendly and biodegradable. Furthermore, La Petite Cafe opened during a pandemic, which the owner acknowledged with characteristic confidence: “Of course, why not?” As a result, the community response was immediate and sustained — something the owner described as genuinely humbling.

The ABBA PaniniBest seller — Ryan’s order, highly recommended
Chicken Salad on Honey WheatMichael’s choice — fresh, clean flavors
Cheese Quesadilla — Tomato BasilWith a cup of veggie soup on the side
Lemon CelloRyan’s bonus order — hand-crafted, fresh

Utter Sensation Ice Cream and What This All Means for Monticello

03
Utter Sensation Ice Cream and What This All Means

Furthermore, La Petite Cafe Monticello operates inside Utter Sensation at the corner of Main and Harrison. Specifically, Utter Sensation serves all-natural 14% butterfat ice cream from the Chocolate Shoppe in Madison, Wisconsin. Additionally, the shop offers over 24 flavors including pints, sundaes, and the Tornado. A second location operates at Indiana Beach.

Moreover, the combination of La Petite Cafe Monticello and Utter Sensation reflects the growing quality of Monticello’s downtown — appealing to buyers considering a move. As a result, Episode 2 is genuinely funny and a meaningful showcase of downtown Monticello’s food scene. Our visit to The Lyme Eatery and Oak & Barrel feature tell the same story from different angles.

Frequently Asked Questions — La Petite Cafe Monticello Indiana

Where is La Petite Cafe in Monticello Indiana?
La Petite Cafe is located at 138 South Main Street in Monticello Indiana — inside the Utter Sensation ice cream shop at the corner of Main and Harrison on the south end of downtown. The cafe can be found on Facebook as “La Petite Cafe Monticello.”
What does La Petite Cafe serve in Monticello?
La Petite Cafe serves fresh sandwiches, wraps, paninis, salads, quesadillas, and soups — all made with hand-cut fresh ingredients and no bagged lettuce. Their menu includes items like the ABBA Panini (best seller), chicken salad on honey wheat, cheese quesadilla with tomato basil, and a lemon cello drink. All packaging is eco-friendly and biodegradable.
What is Utter Sensation ice cream in Monticello Indiana?
Utter Sensation is an ice cream shop at the corner of Main and Harrison in Monticello Indiana — serving all-natural 14% butterfat ice cream from the Chocolate Shoppe Ice Cream Company in Madison, Wisconsin. Offering 24+ flavors, pints, sundaes, and the Tornado dessert, Utter Sensation also has a second location at Indiana Beach.

More About Monticello and Redlow Group

Is downtown Monticello Indiana worth visiting?
Yes — Monticello’s downtown has been growing its dining, retail, and community scene with businesses like La Petite Cafe, The Lyme Eatery, Oak & Barrel, and El Rancho Mexican Grocery all adding character and quality to the town center. The downtown corridor along Main Street is increasingly worth a visit for both residents and visitors to the area.
Who is Cody Miller at Redlow Group?
Cody Miller is a real estate agent at Redlow Group — known on camera as “The Negotiator” and apparently also your mom’s favorite realtor. He is a licensed Indiana agent serving buyers and sellers across White County and northwest Indiana, and the keeper of a 100-year-old family sandwich recipe that he has so far refused to share with the public.
How can I buy a home near downtown Monticello Indiana?
Contact Redlow Group through redlowgroup.com/contact/ to discuss available homes near downtown Monticello, the lakes, and all the local businesses and community amenities that make White County a genuinely great place to live.

Ready to Take a Bite Out of Real Estate?

Redlow Group serves buyers, sellers, and investors across Monticello and White County with local expertise.

  • 1.Buyer and seller representation across Monticello, White County, and northwest Indiana
  • 2.Professional photography, drone footage, and multi-channel digital marketing
  • 3.Local knowledge from a team that actually lives, eats, and works in this community
  • 4.No sandwich required — but La Petite Cafe is right down the road for your next consultation

Episode 2 follows Cody Miller’s legendary sandwich stack and a visit to La Petite Cafe Monticello — where hand-cut fresh salads and eco-friendly packaging reflect exactly what downtown Monticello deserves. Specifically, the owner opened the cafe to fill a genuine gap for fresh lunch options downtown. As a result, the community response was immediate and sustained. Furthermore, operating inside Utter Sensation with over 24 flavors and a location at Indiana Beach, this Main Street destination is one of Monticello’s best food experiences.

Cody’s sandwiches were never going to win. Downtown Monticello Indiana is better for La Petite Cafe being in it.

— Redlow Group
Your Monticello Indiana Real Estate Experts  ·  redlowgroup.com

·

·

More

Back To Top